National Democratic Congress and Corruption in Ghana

Headlines:

Grab the widget  Tech Dreams

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Fighting corruption: strong institutions needed



By: Sheila Okyere


Ghana was ranked the 69th most corrupt country in the world this year according to Transparency International, making it the second year in a row. This unenviable position puts a question mark on whether Ghana’s governments’ promise to curb corruption is in fact a proposition to be taken serious.

Amidst many political endeavours to curb the cancer of corruption in Ghana, it still seems to retain its clutches on most sectors of the country. From government officials to chief executives and heads of educational institutions, corruption is steadily decaying our country’s credibility as a democratic nation.

Bribes and facilitation payments seem to be the norm. From the market seller paying the policeman at the barrier to the multinational firm executive paying the government official to speed up the process of their contract, it is deemed the way of life. Even doctors are found to be benefiting from life threatening situations... These kinds of practices are hindering the economic development of the country.

In recent years, Ghana has managed to preserve political stability and is a prime example of a democratic nation in Africa, but can the same be said about the approach to tackling corruption? Or have the governments and other culpable sectors become a lot cleverer at concealing their corrupt ways?

Every government talks of how important tackling corruption is and eradicating it is a prime policy, but the question is how many are actually successful with this and how many of the government’s own officials are not culprits themselves?

Though when asked, most would say that the public sector and government officials are the most corrupt, Global Integrity 2008 found that the majority of citizens of Ghana deemed the Police Service to be the most corrupt. Corruption in the police can range from individual officers taking bribes and unofficial payments, to evidence in major cases going missing for example, when a large quantity of cocaine was seized by the Ghana Police but never accounted for. The problem with cleaning up this sector is that the Inspector General of Police (IGP) is appointed by the president, so there is the fear that the position can be used as a political instrument for the ruling party.

Also it seems as though there is an inadequate procedure in place to formally complain about the police, which means that officers are rarely prosecuted, disciplined or dismissed. People rarely report corruption to the police through the criminal justice mechanism due to long bureaucratic procedures and a lack of legal protection for prosecution witnesses. The introduction of organisations such as Ghana Integrity Initiative (GII), Commission on Human Rights and Administrative Justice (CHRAJ) and the Serious Frauds Office (SFO) was meant to prevent individuals from going unpunished if found guilty of corruption. Over the years these organisations have been plagued with rumours that they have been systematically starved of funds and in effect, governments have adroitly turned those institutions into pawns while manipulating public feelings that they are fighting corruption. The Serious Fraud Office if funded adequately should by now have been well-established and supported to perform its legitimate functions. Instead, it appears to be falling prey to the ferocious political game that the party in power lures it into. The truth is that neither the SFO nor CHRAJ is effective as consequently, no cases of corruption have been prosecuted in the past 10 years through the criminal justice mechanism of the CHRAJ and the SFO.

US President Barack Obama said when he addressed Africa on his first sub Saharan, that the end to corruption is the key to unlocking Africa's potential. Aimed at potential leaders, he stated that "No country is going to create wealth if its leaders exploit the economy to enrich themselves, or police can be bought off by drug traffickers...No business wants to invest in a place where the government skims 20% off the top ... No person wants to live in a society where the rule of law gives way to the rule of brutality and bribery. That is not democracy, that is tyranny, and now is the time for it to end. Africa doesn't need strongmen, it needs strong institutions." GII, CHRAJ and SFO can take advice from President Obama and the way in which laws are enforced in the USA. Their law does not only bark, it bites very deep as it doesn’t matter who is implicated; the law will not exempt anybody who falls foul of it. That’s why their citizens fear the law as they know that they will not be spared. For instance, the case of the former Governor of Illinois, Rod Blagojevich and the former Congressman Jefferson whose corrupt deals reached Africa and Ghana and for which, he was convicted. Even officials at the White House face the full rigours of the law if they misbehave. The opposite seems to be happening in Ghana as the individuals that are entrusted with interpreting, enacting and enforcing the law are the first to flout it with impunity. The fear of the law seems to be missing in everybody and even though there are ostentatious designs on paper to fight corruption, which every government functionary openly refers to, the need to comply with the law seems to be absent. This casts some doubt about how determined Ghana is and if she is prepared to do the right thing to stem corruption and purge herself of greed.

Recent research shows that the majority of citizens are in fact willing to pay extra for corruption-free products. This is an indication that people are against corruption and that even though it is seen as a way of life; people are still reluctant to accept that not much can be done about it.

This is not to say that the purge can happen overnight; after all it is deeply embedded in numerous areas of the country, but steps taken genuinely in fighting this cancerous ‘disease’ can show the rest of Africa and the world that Ghana as a nation is an advocate for democracy and strong institutions - not only as a country that believes in free and fair elections but also one that believes that no citizen is above the law. Once that understanding is in place and a zero tolerance approach taken, striving for a country free of corruption may seem more achievable and realistic. President Obama struck the nail on the head when he called for strong institutions as enough to stem corruption. With this, individuals will not be tempted to indulge in it and that is how countries brave the storm and move forward. Ghana must move forward too and become a good example for the rest of Africa...

By: Sheila Okyere

Just Ten Months Into Office…Prof. Attah MILLS BEGINS MASSIVE MANSION!

By Kwadwo Yeboah BREMAN- ModernGhana.com

Click for Full Image Size
Just Ten Months Into Office…Prof. Attah MILLS BEGINS MASSIVE MANSION!

A wise man told me not to argue with fools, because people from a distance can't tell who is who. - By: Jay-Z ( The Take Over )
More Quotes | Submit a Quote
Advertize Here for $8 a day to reach over 30,000 people
Ghana Tourist Villas Offers an unforgettable holiday and business experience in Accra.
The President John Evans Attah Mills has bought a land worth hundred and eighty Million old cedis (Gh 18,000) and has commenced with the building of a massive mansion on the land within 10 months in office as the president of the Republic of Ghana!

Currently, the project is uncompleted, but the building, which is located at the Edina (Elmina) Essaman close to Ataabadze junction in the Komenda Edina Eguafo Abirem in the Central Region of Ghana, is moving ahead rapidly!

Investigations conducted by Modernghana news indicate that the said land was originally leased by the late father of President Atta Mills for farming purposes, but the lease lapsed a few years back. At the time Senior Atta Mills was a lecturer at the Komenda Training College in the same district.

The land was originally meant for coconut and citrus plantation, Investigation conducted by this reporter reveals that the late father of the president paid a token to the Essaman Nsona Royal Family who are the owners of the land with the acquisition agreement was to be renewed after twenty-five (25) years.

Our investigations in the community last week revealed that after the lease period lapsed, and following the death of Senior Atta Mills, the owners of the land informed President Mills and his siblings they will not allow the place to be used for farming activities again because the area has become a residential area. In that direction they divided the land into two and sold half to the President for an amount of one hundred and eighty million for the land.

Modernghana.com learned through various interviews in the community that the money was paid to the chief of the community Nana Kwasi Tano IV, but the chief allegedly kept part of the money and gave the rest to the owners of the land the Essaman Nsona Royal Family, but this made them angry, leading to all out war between the Chief and the land owners.

Highly placed sources at the Elmina Traditional Council told this newspaper that the case has been reported there for solution and the Elmina Chief has alleged spoken to the president about it.

Modernghana.com has learned that a sister of the president, Madam Efe Mills who is the wife of Professor Afful of the University of Cape Coast has always been chasing the Essaman Nsona Royal family to sign the land documents, but the family has refused because they did not receive the full payment of one hundred and eighty million which Professor Mills is supposed to have paid to the Chief.

The main person fronting for the building of the mansion is his brother Samuel Mills who was in America with Cadman Mills. As at Friday when this reporter led scouts to the property, the person acting as caretaker of the properties on the land was the president's nephew called Theophilus .

Local inhabitants are deeply unhappy and told this reporter that they are very annoyed with the President because within this short period he has put up a mansion in the area, with his nephews, who have all suddenly become rich, also chasing lands to buy. They said that the President promised to improve their lot and bring jobs to the area, but the improvement is only happening in the lives of his family members, whilst the jobs is only construction work on his mansion and working on pigs for his farm.
Source: Kwadwo Yeboah BREMAN- ModernGhana.com

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

GIS, CEPS to sack corrupt officers …To serve as deterrent to others


By Charles Takyi - Boadu - Ghanaian Chronicle

Click for Full Image Size
I don't know the key success but the key to failure is trying to please everybody - By: Bill Cosby
More Quotes | Submit a Quote
Advertize Here for $8 a day to reach over 30,000 people
Ghana Tourist Villas Offers an unforgettable holiday and business experience in Accra.
The Ghana Immigration Service (GIS) and the Customs Excise and Preventive Service (CEPS) have vowed to weed out the supposed 'few' bad nuts among them from the Services. This was after a data gathered by the Legal Resources Centre (LRC) indicted the two security agencies together with the Ghana Police Service (GPS) of massive corruption.

The data report which was gathered between the periods of September and October 2009 by three separate teams revealed serious delays and widespread corruption along the Tema-Ouagadougou trade corridor.

In a swift response to the research findings, the Head of Communications of the Ghana Immigration Service, DSI Francis Palmdeti said the GIS was prepared to dismiss any individual or group of persons who are proven to have compromised their conscience for money.

He has, therefore, encouraged those who fall victim to some of these corrupt practices to report the officers involved for prompt action, since they were not prepared to sacrifice the name and reputation of the service for anything.

On his part, Assistant Collector Phillip Amoh of the Public Relations Department of the CEPS gave the Service's commitment to institute punitive measures against officers who indulge in corrupt practices to serve as a deterrent to others who may be harbouring the intention to take bribes.

Speaking at the report launched in Accra yesterday, Director of Programmes at the LRC, Ms. Daphne Lariba Nabila talked of serious delays and widespread corruption along the trade route where drivers were stopped not less than 24 times, which averages to 2.3 times per 100km.

She noted that CEPS agents have set up the most checkpoints with an average of 9.5 stops per trip while the GPS averaged 6.5 stops per trip. In Ghana, the report indicates that drivers paid from GH ¢2.00 to GH ¢3.00 in bribes per stop, with CEPS officers accepting no less than GH ¢3.00.

The report further has it that on any given day, the number of trucks plying the route can reach 120, thereby making the total amounts of bribes collected estimated to reach GH ¢12,000 per day, GH ¢84,000 per week, GH ¢360,000 per month and GH ¢4,380,000 per year.

In addition, the report further noted that each of these stop causes delay, particularly when drivers try to bargain, indicating “on every journey, drivers were delayed from 5 to 20minutes per stop. On an average journey, it is said that a driver will be delayed a total of 5hours which averages to 29minutes per 100km. At the Ghanaian border for instance, the report indicates that GIS officer collected a minimum of GH ¢5.00 bribes per person and often asked for more.

In order instances, a traveler with all documents crossing the Ghana border to Burkina Faso was said to have been asked to pay GH ¢20.00 and when he offered to pay only GH ¢15.00, he was detained in custody for not less than 45minutes whilst those who were unable to pay were not allowed to cross the border.

The report further reveals that foreign nationals travelling in Ghana are stopped more frequently, and pay higher bribes than their Ghanaian counterparts, stating “Burkinabe businessmen travelling from Kumasi to Paga endured 19 stops by Police and CEPS, and paid a total of GH ¢48.00 in bribes per person. It was thus noted that it took them 12hours to complete their trip. Ghanaians on the other hand were said to have endured 10hours with 15 stops and a total of GH ¢35.00 in bribes per person.

Ms Nabila thus believes that these practices are a direct violation of obligations under the ECOWAS treaty to “grant full and unrestricted freedom of transit through its territory for goods proceeding to or from a third country…and such transit shall not be subject to any discrimination, quantitative restrictions, duties or other charges.”

Meanwhile, information available indicates that there are more stops in Ghana than in Burkina Faso and for that matter, drivers are unlawfully charged a total of 20,000 CFA to enter Burkina Faso and 12,000 CFA to exit.

Once inside Burkina Faso it is said that there are no less than 3 stop s before Ouagadougou whilst travelers pay 50 CFA at a toll booth.

However, a report released by the Improved Road Transport Governance (IRTG) initiative on interstate trade corridors for the second quarter of 2009 has it that the number of checkpoints have increased by 6% whilst the value of bribes collected have increased by 24% and the delays caused by checkpoints increased by 11%.

But Ms. Nabila attributes some of these worsening trends to the introduction of axle-load weight restrictions. This, according to her, was because “agents at axle-load weighbridge stations will fine drivers for being overloaded but do not provide a receipt to legitimize the transaction”, stressing “in Ghana, agents operating toll booths and weighbridges collected the most bribes, followed by Customs agents, then Police officers and finally Immigration officers.”

As a result of the widespread practice of corruption along the Tema-Ouagadougot route, the LRC says “drivers and traders are growing to accept bribery and long delays as the order of the day”, emphasizing “some drivers set bribe money aside for Police, Customs and Immigration officers along the route.”

According to the Centre, such additional costs are one of the reasons why transportation in West Africa has become the most inefficient and most expensive in the world, stressing “inevitably, these higher costs of transport are added to the price of goods and are passed on to consumers in Ghana and neighbouring countries.”
Source: Charles Takyi - Boadu - Ghanaian Chronicle

Transparency & Accountability slogan suffers a jolt


MILLS` PAL SWEATS OVER ¢12BN DEBT
… As Forestry Commission vows to strip Jowak naked


By Bismark Bebli | Posted: Tuesday, December 01, 2009

Alhaji Collins Dauda, Minister for Lands and Natural Resources
Alhaji Collins Dauda, Minister for Lands and Natural Resources
Austerity measures put in place by President Millls to put the economy back on track, appears to have suffered a jolt, following the discovery that Mr. John Owusu Amankrah, Managing Director of Jowak Sawn Mills Limited, who was recently appointed to the board of the Forestry Commission (FC) by the president, owes the same institution he is supposed to superintend ¢12 billion.

The debt is said to have brought the FC’s finances to its knees, but all efforts to get the board member to settle his indebtedness have proved futile.

Mr. John Owusu Amankrah admitted that his company owes the FC, but denied the ¢12b figure being bandied around.

He claims the FC also owes him ¢14 billion, which has not been settled. This reporter gathered that following the refusal of Jowak to settle the indebtedness, the Chief Executive officer (CEO) of the FC, Prof. Nii Ashie Kotey, wrote a strongly-worded letter dated September 2, 2007 to the former, asking him to pay the money or face the consequences.

The letter, which was under the caption ‘Demand notice/legal action,’ stated “Your Company was requested to fulfill some requirements, as well as pay fully for the volume of teak trees to be harvested. Up to date, your company has an outstanding balance of GH¢1,243,047.46 to be paid, which contravenes the conditions under which the permit was granted.

“Your company has been given up to September 15, 2008 to make all its financial obligations to the Forestry Commission without fail. From September 15, 2008, the Commission will resort to the following against your company - Stop your operations, publish your company’s name in the print and electronic media as a defaulter, and therefore not of good standing, and resort to legal action against your company.”

The Chronicle learnt that Jowak could not meet the above demand issued to the company by the CEO before the New Patriotic Patrty (NPP) lost power.

When National Democratic Congress (NDC) took over, they also gave the company another period to settle the debt, which expired on September 25th this year, but the company has still failed to pay the money into government chest.

Surprisingly, the powers that be, have gone ahead to offer another concession to the company to harvest teak trees.

In a letter dated July 6th 2009, Mr. F. S. Amoah. Director of Plantations, directed some of the zonal plantation managers in the Ashanti and Brong Ahafo regions to provide uninterrupted services to the company to harvest logs that fall within their jurisdictions. “You are hereby directed to allow the company to operate, and provide them with uninterrupted services,” the letter stated.

This development is said to have incurred the displeasure of some of the board members, who think the decision infringes upon the transparency and accountability being preached by the government.

Mr. John Owusu Amankrah told The Chtronicle, when he was contactedthat he owes the FC ¢9 billion and not ¢12 billion. According to him, the debt emanated from the auction of forest reserves to him at the cost of ¢60 billion, which has paid, leaving a balance of ¢9 billion.

He also claimed the FC also owes him ¢14 billion in loans he granted the commission. According to him, somewhere in 2007, the FC approached him for a loan. As part of the agreement, the then sector Minister, Cecilia Obeng Dapaah, gave him concession to harvest trees to cover the debt.

He however regretted that an injuction had been placed on the forest that was allocated to him, so he has not been able to harvest the trees to recoup his money.

The Chronicle

Ghana:Castle Boys Fight Over Cash



PrintE-mail

Image
John Martey Newman
Confusion is raging over the salaries of members of the National Democratic Congress (NDC) who were employed to work at National Security and the Seat of Government since the party came to power this year, and ‘betrayal’ best describes their mood.

DAILY GUIDE has information that the said workers have pounced on the Chief of Staff, Martey Newman, for their unpaid salaries and have threatened to prove their importance and defend their rights if the money is not released to them.

They have also threatened that unless they are given the money due them, they would expose any party appointee who receives any ‘back door’ envelop or money for logistics and party work.

While many of them have not received any salary since they were employed in February this year, a handful of them were given only two months’ salary a few weeks ago, with an explanation that the rest would not be paid them because their working conditions had just been regularized.

The workers are mostly security operatives around the President and his Vice, Protocol Officers, office attendants, drivers and ‘hangers-on’ who were employed on the basis of their party loyalty and not through the main stream civil service.

Reports say since February, the workers were given a monthly allowance of GH¢300 each until last month when they protested and insisted on receiving salaries and not allowances.

The Chief of Staff was thus directed to prepare their salaries, but they became more infuriated when Mr. Newman, after the said preparation of salaries, handed them a two-month’s salary each, with some of them receiving nothing.

To make matters worse, many of them had their allowances slashed by as much as 50 percent, with an explanation that things would get better soon so they should hold on for better times ahead.

The explanation seems not to have gone down well with the workers who insist their contribution to the party’s victory is not different from that of other party appointees who are believed to be receiving bigger booties and living in luxury.

The workers have explained that they feel cheated because a number of persons who were passive during the campaign for power and many others who were not even part of the campaign, have been given lucrative appointments while some even travel with the President and enjoy juicy booties in the name of the party.

By Halifax Ansah-Addo

Sunday, November 29, 2009

GHANA:$850,000 fraud case takes another turn

The $850,000 fraud case involving two lawyers took another turn Thursday when the trial judge who had been authorised by the Chief Justice and the Attorney-General to hear the matter told parties in the case that he had been restrained from further hearing the matter by a High Court judge.

The trial judge, Mr D. E. K. Daketsey, told the prosecution and the defence teams that he had been served with an order of injunction restraining him from hearing the case until the determination of a suit brought against him by the two lawyers.

According to the judge, the lawyers, Joseph Kwame Owusu Asamani and Ekow Amua-Sekyi, who are facing charges of forgery and fraud, sought the order from the Human Rights Court, presided over by Mr Justice U. P. Dery, last Friday.

According to counsel for the two lawyers, Mr James Agalga, November 12, 2009 had been fixed for hearing the motion for an order of prohibition directed at the judge whom his clients had accused of making bias statements against them.

The prosecution had stated that the two allegedly prepared a Deed of Assignment, unknown to the complainant, Gordon Etroo, scanned his signature on it, registered it at the Lands Registry and presented it to Howard Eric Ewen, the Managing Director of Keegan Resources, who also signed.

On March 18, 2007, the two allegedly forged a judgement titled 'Axex Company Limited versus four other defendants' and inserted an order by a High Court judge for the recovery of a mine known as Bonte Esaase Gold Mine.

According to the prosecution, the two lawyers, without the knowledge of Samuel Etroo and Mr Kwame Opoku, initiated a civil suit number BL35/07, as 'Kwame Opoku versus Sametro Company Limited'.

However, the two have not appeared before the court to answer the charges.

The trial judge, Mr Daketsey, who did not disclose the grounds of the injunction, said he had since been served with a writ of prohibition by the two lawyers.

The lawyers were said to have sought the order on the grounds that the judge was likely to show bias if he went ahead to hear the case against them.

The judge told prosecutors and defence lawyers that he had instructed his solicitors to contest the case because he had no personal interest or whatsoever in the case.

He also told the parties in his chambers that he felt aggrieved because the two lawyers had, on a countless number of occasions, refused to appear in his court to answer charges levelled against them.

Obviously aggrieved at the turn of events, Nana Ato Dadzie, who is counsel for the complainant in the case, told journalists that the common practice was for the lawyers to be in court to state why they were absent.

He said the case had had a chequered history because it took more than two years for the lawyers to be put before court.

He said the Attorney-General called for the docket for study and on October 22, 2008 she formally wrote to the court authorising it to proceed with the case, adding that the Chief Justice had also authorised the judge to hear the case.

Nana Ato Dadzie said although the two lawyers were at liberty to go for a prohibition order, he was of the view that such antics were calculated to frustrate the court process.

He also indicated that his client was an interested party and he, therefore, intended to join the suit the Human Rights Court.

He further indicated that the interest of justice would be served if all parties had their day in court.

No definite date has been fixed for the hearing of the criminal matter due to the latest twist.


Source: Daily Graphic/Ghana

Thursday, November 26, 2009

NDC Corruption: DFID Whistleblower Says £18m Vanished In '99



Is Britain's aid money well spent? One expert working in Ghana raised doubts - and was sacked. Rosie Waterhouse on the whistle-blower and the missing £18m Howard Horsley is an idealist, committed to overseas aid.

Over the years he has worked as a volunteer, a paid teacher and a VSO field officer in Africa. Then, in 1999, at the age of 54 and with a successful career as a headteacher in England behind him, he applied for a job with the Department for International Development (DfID).

"I was thrilled by the expansion of the overseas aid programme under the newly elected Labour government and keen to make my expertise available," he recalls. In May that year he took up a post managing the education field office (EFO) in Ghana, administering a British aid programme worth £50m over five years.

He liked Accra, the capital, and made plans for his wife to join him, but within a few weeks he began to notice things at work that he didn't like. As months passed, he grew more and more concerned about what he describes as "lax financial controls, unchecked powers of patronage and the potential for mismanagement and corruption".

He reported these concerns to DfID in London in e-mails, memos and telephone conversations. Yet, instead of seeing them investigated, Horsley was summarily sacked and denied a reference. It was a personal calamity. For the past five years, this former head of a tough Grimsby comprehensive, who has a glowing Ofsted report on his record, has been unable to find work. With the vigorous support of the MP Austin Mitchell, who describes his treatment as "monstrous", Horsley has fought to have his case reviewed and his complaints investigated. Now he has decided to tell his story.

It is a story that raises important questions about DfID's control over aid spending - at a time when the G8 summit has just agreed to double aid to Africa by 2010, and when our government is assuring us that our aid money is not seeping away through corruption and poor management. And, while the government insists it has done nothing wrong, uncertainty remains about its past procedures and about the fate of no less than £18m in aid.

More worrying still, it is now clear that Horsley was not the first British aid official in Accra to raise doubts about financial control. At the time he went to Accra, Britain's policy for distributing aid had shifted from big projects to local programmes administered through the Ghana Education Service, with staff at the British education field office working alongside officials in the Ghanaian education ministry.

Horsley soon heard complaints from other aid agencies, and from the Ghanaian minister and his officials, about the way money was spent and contracts awarded without adequate accounting or monitoring by DfID. Incidents included a request to authorise spending of £32,000 on office furniture, when the furniture had already been bought; the failure of DfID to provide the Ghanaian education minister with a full statement of how education aid was being spent, and the potential use of aid as, in Horsley's words, "a means of dispensing personal favours".

The most mysterious incident came after Horsley was told by the Ghanaian deputy education minister in August 1999 that Clare Short, the then secretary of state for international development, had pledged an extra £18m in aid. When none of this money turned up, Horsley made inquiries with the Ghanaian accountant general - who, he says, confirmed in September 1999 that it had been received by the government.

The money, however, did not find its way into the usual education aid channels, so Horsley, alarmed about the fate of such a sum and about the other problems he had found, wrote to London requesting a formal, independent investigation of the conduct of DfID affairs in Ghana.

Soon afterwards, on a working trip to northern Ghana, he caught typhoid and returned to Britain to recuperate. On his recovery he was called to a meeting at DfID headquarters on 6 January 2000. He thought this was to discuss the investigation he had requested and also to complete his midterm performance review, but he arrived to find that it was a disciplinary hearing. It didn't last long. Blamed for a breakdown in communication and a lack of coherence in the presentation of policy, he was sacked with immediate effect. Horsley strenuously denied the charges and received strong support from international colleagues, but, when he returned to Ghana to assemble evidence for his appeal, he found that his filing cabinets had been emptied and his computer files professionally wiped.

DfID then withdrew his formal right of appeal and threatened him with the Official Secrets Act if he spoke out. Claiming protection as a whistle-blower under the Public Interest Disclosure Act, Horsley sought to have his dismissal investigated first by DfID itself and then at an employment tribunal. The tribunal said it had no jurisdiction because he had not been employed for long enough and had not lodged his Public Interest Disclosure Act claim soon enough.

The civil service commissioners brushed him off, too, saying they could not investigate as DfID claimed he was employed on contract, not as a civil servant. The case has outraged Austin Mitchell, who raised it in the House of Commons and has written to Hilary Benn, the current Secretary of State of International Development, asking for an independent inquiry. Mitchell told the New Statesman: "As a result of his attempt to blow the whistle on financial inadequacies and possible maladministration, this man has been out of a job for nearly six years and that's a monstrous way for DfID to behave.

They made Howard a sacrificial victim. He was an embarrassment in raising these concerns. The proper procedure should have been to investigate complaints and tighten up procedures. They didn't do that." One body that has investigated DfID aid to Ghana is the National Audit Office (NAO), which reported in a letter to Mitchell: "At no point . . . has any evidence emerged to suggest that financial impropriety or mismanagement occurred within DfID."

But the letter added that "investigations revealed areas where the department might usefully tighten up its procedures and controls, which they are doing". As for the mysterious £18m, the audit office initially said that DfID claimed no such amount had been paid to Ghana in 1999. Then, in May 2003, the NAO admitted that £18m had been paid, in 2000, as "budgetary support". It explained: "It follows that for payments of budgetary support it is not possible directly to answer the questions 'What was it for?' or 'How was it spent?', except to say that it added to the resources available to the government of Ghana." This is a remarkable admission: put bluntly, it means that neither DfID nor the NAO could say what became of £18m of British taxpayers' money.

Since that investigation, the NAO has tightened up accounting procedures for aid spending in general and for "budgetary support" in particular. Howard Horsley is entitled to some credit for this, though he has had no thanks for his efforts. DfID maintains that any weaknesses in its financial procedures have been addressed and that Horsley's dismissal was "wholly related to his performance, which did not meet the requirements of the job".

It says: "All parties across Whitehall have been satisfied that DfID acted correctly in relation to Mr Horsley's dismissal and found no evidence of financial impropriety." Horsley authorised DfID to release documents to the New Statesman to clarify the grounds for dismissal. He says they prove that DfID never carried out the investigation he requested weeks before his dismissal and also that it ignored its own disciplinary procedures in sacking him.

But the story does not end there, for, in the course of his campaign, Horsley discovered he was not alone in raising concerns about aid to Ghana. His predecessor there had raised similar doubts about an "absence of checks and balances". Howard Tyers, who now works at Westminster University, has confirmed to the New Statesman that in his time at the Accra EFO he made "a number of complaints" about payments for an expensive office and also for Land Cruisers of an unnecessarily high specification, purchased without the usual tendering process.

Worryingly, after these complaints Tyers's tenure in Ghana also ended strangely. His contract ended in March 1999, but he asked for a three-month extension because he had to remain resident in Ghana, as his daughter was completing her A-levels. This request was rejected in London, and it was only after an appeal by the Ghanaian education ministry that he was allowed to stay.

However, he was sidelined to a research project and denied access to the EFO. And, like Horsley, he found his computer files wiped. The experiences of Horsley and his predecessor raise questions that should worry anyone who cares about aid. Does DfID respond properly to concerns about financial management? Does it ensure that new aid is spent wisely, with transparency and adequate financial controls? DfID says yes, but unless whistle-blowers are encouraged and protected, how can we be sure?

How does Horsley feel? "Angry that DfID has still held no one accountable for what was going on in Ghana; that no one has been held accountable for my entirely unjustified dismissal; that there has been no hearing, anywhere, on the merits of my case. And appalled that DfID can demand good governance in other countries and still fail to meet the most basic standards of good governance in its own internal practices."

He is angry, too, at the waste of years of his career. Despite the emotional and financial costs, he remains determined not to let the matter drop. Transparency International, which campaigns against corruption in aid and trade, would not comment on the case, but its executive director, Chandrashekhar Krishnan, was clear about one thing: "Any development organisation should have a policy of encouraging whistle-blowers and of ensuring that, if someone has suspicions to report, there is a mechanism to allow that person to express those concerns in a way which will not attract recriminations." The Horsley case does not seem to match that standard and it will deter, not encourage, future whistle-blowers.

Source: The Statesman - The Statesman

No wonder education in Ghana under NDC, Rawlings and Mills suffered a serious set back because of corruption.

Sunday, November 22, 2009

Malpractices uncovered in NHIA in Volta - Akototse

Ho, GNA - Mr Elliot Nestor Akototse, Volta Regional Manager of the National Health Insurance Authority (NHIA), has said that serious malpractices were uncovered during "clinical auditing" of the scheme in the region.

He said that the NHIA would evaluate the findings and take the necessary actions.

Mr Elliot Nestor Akototse was speaking at the opening of a three-day strategic planning seminar for personnel of the National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) in the Volta Region, in Ho on Friday. The seminar which was on the theme: "Delivering on the NHIS promise", was to brainstorm on the successes and challenges of the policy five years after it was started, and to strategize to strengthen it. Mr Joseph Amenowode, the Regional Minister, who opened the seminar, promised to facilitate efforts aimed at preventing people from sabotaging the scheme.

The Minister said that he was aware that some miscreants had been identified in the exercises and that Volta Regional Coordinating Council (VRCC) would help tackle fraudulent deals. "We members of VRCC shall broaden and intensify our monitoring and coordinating activities to strike out and bring to book persons whose activities seek to frustrate the suucessful implementation of the NHIS in the region and the country at large", Mr Amenowode said. Mr Syvelster Mensah, Chief Executive Officer of the NHIA, in a speech read for him, said the Authority would provide training to raise the competencies of the staff and also build administrative linkages among the various schemes on one hand and the schemes and Authority on the other hand. He said that managers of the scheme would be required to sign performance contracts and that "performance management would now be a very vital part of our staff appraisal and reward system".
Source:
GNA

Fighting Corruption is a Must!

What some of us have feared all these years appears to be manifesting. We have been apprehensive that although the various governments of this country have indulged in loud but empty rhetoric about fighting corruption, they are least prepared to do so practically. Either by design or a willful determination to subvert their own measures to fight corruption, these governments have done one thing in one breath against corruption only to undo that very thing in the same breath.

While the various Presidents in this 4th Republic have declared openly their determination to fight corruption, they have failed to provide the practical support to institutions and people entrusted with the anti-corruption drive. It happened under JJ Rawlings and was intensified under Kufuor. Now, under President Mills, that same picture has been painted. Corruption is rife in Ghana and Ghana’s position on the global corruption index has not changed in any positive way because the government lacks what it takes to stem corruption. There is no hope for us if what has been happening doesn’t abate.

And now, if one bold individual stands up to lead the fight against corruption, his life is endangered. A justice of the High Court, Mr Justice Iddrisu Mahamadu says his life is in danger following the trial and conviction of six policemen and four civilians for robbery over which he presided. The threat to Justice Mahamadu’s life was reported to the Inspector-General of Police, Mr. Paul Tawiah Quaye, by the Chief Justice, Mrs. Justice Georgina Wood. In her report, the Chief Justice told the IGP that following the conviction of the six policemen and four civilians by Justice Mahamadu, he has received numerous threats to his life.

The scenario at the court premises portended what is being dreaded today. As reported (Reference: JoyFM Online, Saturday, November 21, 2009):

“Soon after their conviction, some of their family members wailed and vented their anger on the judge and some journalists outside the courtroom. They openly cursed and rained unprintable insults on the trial judge, who was escorted to his vehicle by court clerks and policemen.”

That’s not the first time such a negative conduct has come to notice. When Justice Henrietta Abban convicted Tsatsu Tsikata, she was subjected to similar threats and name-calling. Others have had their share of such ill-treatment even if not reported. This appeal for protection for Justice Mahamadu raises several concerns that the government must address immediately. As part of the efforts to fight corruption and crime, the government must go beyond mere political rhetoric and massaging of public feelings.

When the Kufuor government took action to prosecute NDC functionaries it accused of “causing financial loss to the state,” the NDC rose up in arms. Politicized as issues might be, there was evidence that corrupt practices took place and that the individuals being tried were actively involved in it.

At the turn of the political table, the Mills government began taking action against the NPP functionaries whose corrupt acts (e.g., snatching government property) were evident; but what did we see? The NPP elements also rose up in arms, threatening hell-fire and brimstone. As if cowered into submission by such threats, the Mills government budged, creating a bad-blood relationship between itself and the rank and file of the NDC who think that the NPP elements were corrupt and should be punished.

By rising to the defence of those perceived as corrupt, their sympathizers hinder the anti-corruption drive. Can the fight against corruption really succeed if people rush to defend those known for being corrupt? How do we perceive or conceive corruption as a moral canker or socio-economic and political vice that we must fight to the hilt? Corruption is the root cause of the high crime wave that our country faces.

By its very nature, corruption doesn’t mean only bribe-taking, as most people wrongly conclude. Any act that goes contrary to the norm qualifies as corruption. The Christian Gospel gives us a good example in the form of “adultery,” where Jesus says that adultery is committed even if the individual merely looks at the other’s erogenous zone (be that the backside or breasts) and has mental pictures that arouse sexual pleasure. It is something psychological—conceived in the mind’s eye as an imaginary sense of consummation (be it swallowing saliva at the prospects or fantasizing about the pleasure to be derived from a practical conjoining of sexual passions). In effect, the mental picture of sexual appetite alone is enough evidence of adultery (corruption) even if the act itself is not physically carried out in the end.

In the case of corruption in the public or private sectors of national life, we can identify instances:
  • Tribalism and nepotism in the choice and appointment of office holders, recruitment into the security services, or any other institution;
  • Favouritism in the promotion or laying off of workers (especially under the policy of redeployment or retrenchment);
  • Award of contracts (whether going through appropriate layers of bidding or not) to preferred candidates and ripping off profits in the form of kickbacks;
  • Sidestepping official procedures for managing offices and national assignments (e.g., procurement—over-invoicing or under-invoicing for personal gains);
  • Creating conditions conducive to the greasing of palms (e.g., in the nomination and choice of candidates for enstoolment as chiefs/queenmothers; sale of land; etc.); and
  • Giving or accepting gifts (e.g., foodstuffs, money, tangible or intangible items, etc.) before performing functions within one’s purview (doing in office what one was hired to do and be paid for).

The Church and its pastors are known for their crusading sermons against corruption; but how many of them haven’t been taken to task for abusing their office, preaching against immorality but indulging in it? Judges have been accused of bribe-taking; personnel of the security services (e.g., customs and immigration officers) have done corrupt things; the politicians are known for indulging in corrupt practices (wife-snatching, visa racketeering, abuse of office, etc.); civil servants have institutionalized measures to collect bribes from people calling for processing of their documents; the police collect bribe in the open; school administrators collect bribe before they admit students; many more. Who will claim not to be part of this racket of corruption in Ghana?

Communalistic as our Ghanaian body politic is, one accepts the fact that the milk of human kindness flows through our human streams. Thus, it is not strange for someone “to know” another person in authority somewhere who is capable of helping a distressed person in one way or the other. That’s our natural bent. But when this natural bent is overstretched so as to become problematic, we must pause to reconsider it and make amends.

We have reached a stage where such a drastic reconsideration must be made if we want to fight successfully corruption and its attendant negative consequences. Recourse to the laws that prohibit corruption is our first step. But where do we start from?

There appears to be confusion in terms of what constitutes a “gift,” on the one hand, and what amounts to “corruption” (bribery), on the other hand. I have been given to know that somewhere in our Criminal Code (Act 29 of 1960) is a clause that enjoins any member of the Police Service, for instance, who is given any gift by anybody to declare it to the IGP or face severe sanctions. If that is the case, to whom does the IGP declare any gift he/she receives?

The constitution explicitly calls for the declaration of assets by the President and government officials at specific times. But what have we had so far? How will we know their standing at the time they enter office so as not to accuse them of corruption when their assets begin piling up? Do you remember Isaac Edumadze of the NPP while he was in charge of the Central Regional Administration? Now, the searchlight is on Ama Benyiwa-Doe of the NDC. The Northern Regional Minister and the NDC Regional Chairman have been trading accusations of bribery and corruption against each other. Other instances of corruption have come to notice, but the government doesn’t seem to care a rap about such public apprehensions.

Allegations of corruption deserve to be followed up and investigated for us to know what the truth is. Kofi Wayo has already accused President Mills and his NDC government functionaries of positioning themselves to benefit from a $14-million Vodafone bribe, but no one has batted an eyelid in government or the anti-corruption institutions. Hello, Mahama Ayariga and Alban Bagbin; are you there?

The MP for Asikuma-Odoben-Brakwa, P.C. Ofori-Appiah, has cried himself hoarse on bribery allegations against the Kufuor-led NPP government until this era of the NDC. His fellow NPP functionaries derided him as “mad” and pooh-poohed his allegations. Even if he is “mad,” does it mean that his allegations too are “mad”? What has anybody done to follow the numerous leads that he has provided? Instead of doing so, the government is frozen and turns attention elsewhere. How can we truly say that we are interested in fighting corruption if we do not regard allegations against public officials as worth our bother?

Many of those who openly express contempt for Rawlings appear to be doing so because they “hate” him for professing a strong abhorrence for corruption and presiding over the shooting to death or imprisonment of Ghanaians that his military governments (AFRC/PNDC) accused of corruption but failing to live by his own words. The allegations of bribery involving the late Abacha of Nigeria, the Scancem (Norwegian) case, trial of Nana Konadu-Agyemang-Rawlings over Caribdem, and many other instances featuring his name readily come to mind, although no one has yet pinned him down. The point is that such allegations create credibility problems and deflate confidence in the fight against corruption.

Institutions that have been established to fight corruption have been systematically starved of funds and their personnel brow-beaten into fearing for the security of their jobs if they dare perform the very functions for which they were hired and paid monthly. In effect, our governments have adroitly turned those institutions into paper tigers while massaging public feelings that they are fighting corruption.

The Serious Fraud Office should by now have been well-established and supported to perform its legitimate functions. Instead, it appears to be falling prey to the vicious political game that the party in power lures it into. The truth is that the SFO is impotent. As for the CHAJ, it is doomed already.

The Criminal Investigations Department of the Police Service is also mired in corrupt practices by its personnel and has lost public confidence. Under Kufuor, the loss of quantities of cocaine from the custody of the Police and several other corrupt acts by the police personnel themselves over the years have completely dented the image of the Police Service. It cannot purge itself of such a sordid image nor is it clear what it can do to repair it. If the people who are recruited to fight corruption are themselves corrupt, where is the guarantee that the fight against corruption will ever succeed?

We have reached a stage in the handling of national affairs to know that we cannot make any progress if we do not allow the laws of the land to function effectively. We can’t help but turn to the United States for examples. In the U.S., the law doesn’t only bark; it bites very deep. It doesn’t matter who is involved; the law will not spare anybody who falls foul of it. That’s why the US citizens fear the law. They know that they will not be spared. Remember the case of the former Governor of Illinois (Rod Blagojevich) and the former Congressman Jefferson whose corrupt deals reached Ghana for which he has just been convicted? Even officials at the White House face the full rigours of the law if they misbehave.

In our case, it is the reverse because the very people who are entrusted with enacting, interpreting, or enforcing the law are the first to flout it with impunity. Nobody seems prepared to do what will instill “the fear of the law” in anybody. There are grandiose designs on paper to fight corruption, which every government functionary openly refers to, but does not fear or comply with. Human and infallible, though we are, there is hope that if we do the right thing, we will shame the devil. Are we prepared to do the right thing to stem corruption and purge ourselves of greed and filth?

President Mills needs to know that his government cannot escape blame if it does nothing concrete to stem corruption. The fact is that if he presents himself as incorruptible (as JJ Rawlings has bored us with), he will not make any difference. It is the institutions of state that must be strengthened to make corruption unattractive, not one or two individuals projecting themselves as such. When our institutions are strong enough to stem corruption, the individuals will not be tempted to indulge in it. As President Obama has already cautioned us, the time has come for us to break away from the mentality of “strongmen” to that of strong institutions of state! That is how countries brave the storm and move forward. Ghana must move forward too. I challenge President Mills to make the difference in the fight against corruption.


By Dr. Michael J.K. Bokor
E-mail: mjbokor@yahoo.com

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Investigate N/R Minister; NPP youth in Tamale demand

Northern Regional Minister, Stephen Sumani Nayina
Northern Regional Minister, Stephen Sumani Nayina




Youth of the opposition New Patriotic Party in Tamale, want the Mills government to investigate allegations that the Northern Regional Minister sold four pick-ups belonging to the RCC to himself.

The group is also asking that Mr Stephen Sumani Nayina be probed over claims that he dabbled in the sale of contracts in contravention of laws which dictate that such contracts be awarded through a competitive bidding process.

The Northern Regional Chairman of the ruling National Democratic Congress, Alhaji Sumani Zakari last week levelled the allegations against Mr Nayina in a feud that saw the two throwing mud at each other.

The regional Minister denied the allegations, accusing the Chairman of grabbing six out of sixteen road contracts awarded in the region.

But a statement signed by the NPP youth spokesperson Salifu Sule, and issued in Tamale, says the allegations needed to be investigated particularly because they came in the wake of similar ones made against Mr Nayina.

According Joy FM’s Northern Regional Correspondent, Mahama Shaibu, the NPP youth say Mr Nayina’s denials were not enough, arguing only an independent body could exonerate him of the charges.

The group believes the president would be dealing his promise of vigorously fighting corruption a heavy blow, if he failed to investigate the matter.


Story by Malik Abass Daabu/Myjoyonline.com/Ghana

Ghana Pundit Headline News

E-mail

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Oh Corruption